Two short-term bond funds can do the same job for a portfolio and still send very different amounts of money to your bank account. The Schwab Short-Term U.S. Treasury ETF (SCHO) and the Vanguard Short-Term Tax-Exempt Bond ETF (VTES) both park cash in high-quality debt that matures soon. Where they diverge is in what they cost, what they yield on paper, and how much of that yield the IRS takes.
SCHO wins on expenses and on headline yield. VTES offers income that is largely shielded from federal taxes. Which one is the better fit depends mostly on your tax bracket, and the fund with the bigger yield figure on the screen is not always the one that leaves you with more.

Two Funds, One Job, Different Tax Treatment
SCHO holds U.S. Treasury securities with short maturities. Treasuries are backed by the federal government, so credit risk is about as low as it gets in fixed income. Their interest is taxed by Washington as ordinary income, though it is exempt from state and local income taxes. Short maturities also keep the fund’s sensitivity to interest rate swings modest.
VTES takes a different route to the same destination. It holds short-term municipal bonds, debt issued by states, cities and other local entities, whose interest is largely exempt from federal income tax. “Largely” matters here, because a tax-exempt fund can still throw off some taxable income, and some investors may owe the alternative minimum tax on certain municipal interest. Municipal issuers also carry more credit risk than the Treasury does, though the risk is usually small in short-maturity, high-quality portfolios.
Why the Bigger Yield Can Mislead
A tax-exempt yield and a taxable yield are not measured on the same basis. To compare them, convert the tax-free number into what a taxable bond would need to pay to match it. The formula is simple: divide the tax-free yield by one minus your federal tax rate. The higher your bracket, the more a tax-exempt dollar is worth.
Take a purely hypothetical case. Say a Treasury fund yields 4% and a tax-exempt fund yields 3%. For someone in the 12% federal bracket, the Treasury fund keeps about 3.52% after federal tax, so it comes out ahead. At 24%, the Treasury fund nets roughly 3.04%, which is almost a dead heat with the 3.00% from the municipal fund. At 32%, the Treasury fund nets about 2.72%, and the municipal fund pulls clearly ahead.

The same hypothetical shows why the question has no universal answer. The 3% tax-exempt yield is equivalent to about 3.41% taxable at the 12% bracket, 3.95% at 24%, and 4.41% at 32%. Somewhere in the middle brackets, the lower-yielding fund stops looking like the weaker one. The real yields on SCHO and VTES will differ from these round numbers and move with the market, so the exercise is worth repeating with current figures.
State taxes complicate the math further. Treasury interest escapes state and local income tax, which narrows the gap for investors in high-tax states. A national municipal fund like VTES holds bonds from many issuers, and the state-tax benefit generally works best when the bonds come from your own state. Investors in states with no income tax lose that advantage entirely, which tilts the comparison back toward the simpler federal calculation.
Fees and the Account You Hold Them In
SCHO’s lower cost is a real edge, and it counts for more in short-term bond funds than in stock funds. When a fund’s yield is a few percentage points, even a small difference in annual expenses takes a visible bite out of income. That cost advantage also helps explain SCHO’s higher yield, since the less a fund charges, the more of its portfolio’s interest reaches shareholders.
The account matters as much as the fund. Inside an IRA or 401(k), taxes on interest are deferred or eliminated, so VTES’s tax shield has no value there and its cost and yield are all that count. In that setting SCHO is the more natural choice. The tax-exempt fund earns its place only in a taxable brokerage account, where the interest would otherwise show up on your return every year.
Sorting Out Which Fund Fits
Start with where the money sits. If it is in a tax-advantaged retirement account, the comparison is nearly over before it begins, because you would be paying for a tax benefit you cannot use. If it sits in a taxable account, find your marginal federal rate and run the tax-equivalent calculation using each fund’s current yield.
Then consider who you are as an investor. Someone in a lower bracket, or someone who wants Treasury-level credit quality without any asterisk about municipal issuers, has good reasons to lean toward SCHO. Someone in the upper-middle brackets or above, holding cash-like money in a taxable account, has a strong case for the municipal fund despite its lower stated yield and slightly higher cost.

A one-point difference in advertised yield can disappear in a single line of a tax return. Before choosing between the two, check the figure that decides it: what is your marginal rate, and which fund’s yield is still standing once it has been applied?








